Deb Richardson (aka dria) wrote a long thoughtful article on tagging at the Mozilla wiki a month and a half ago. I just noticed it now because I read that the Firefox team is considering some upgrades to the browser chrome and in the newsgroup post where some of the ideas were floated there was a reference to something called the “Places” UI. While reading up on that I found dria’s On Tagging article.
In it, she expresses a lack of interest in social bookmarking services (mainly for privacy reasons) but floats some ideas about how the browser could enable tagging, essentially as a replacement for the typical poor-scaling bookmark element we all know and fail to love.
“Bookmarks Are Dead,” she writes. “All Hail Tagging”:
My idea is that we replace bookmarks entirely with the tagging concept. Instead of bookmarking a page, subscribing to an RSS feed, blah blah, you just tag it. Tagging an item automatically stashes that URL into your profile’s tags file/database. If you’re tagging a web feed, it automatically turns it into a Live bookmark (although we need to get rid of the “bookmark” term entirely…it’s not a book).
I already have the Firefox delicious extension installed, so I’m ready for tightly integrated tagging directly in the browser interface.
Get with the times
Check out http://www.flock.com
Comment by lukin — March 6, 2006 @ 3:17 pm
Ho hum. I downloaded Flock when the beta first became available. I don’t get it. I have to adopt yet another browser that offers a subset of features I like with a few built-in features that can be handled with Firefox extensions?
With the delicious and Performancing extensions available I don’t see the compelling use case for Flock.
Also, if you read Dria’s article, she is not talking about delicious integration. She is talking about personal unshared tags (or sharing them in an anonymous way).
Comment by xian — March 8, 2006 @ 1:11 am